#1
Read-alikes and related books
Books like When We Were Magic
If you loved When We Were Magic by Sarah Gailey, this shelf of 24 books shares the same pull — rooted in Paranormal, Occult & Supernatural, LGBTQ, Fantasy & Magic, and Young Adult Fiction.
Top related books to When We Were Magic
Handpicked for thematic and literary overlap — the best shelf companions to When We Were Magic.
This list brings together 24 books that share meaningful common ground with When We Were Magic by Sarah Gailey. Connected by Paranormal, Occult & Supernatural, LGBTQ, Fantasy & Magic. Authors featured include Taylor Munsell, Erica Waters, Rebecca Podos, Louangie Bou-Montes, and others. Each pick was selected for thematic and literary overlap — not just genre similarity.
