Read-alikes and related books

Books like The Prodigal

Explore 24 books like The Prodigal by Beverly Lewis — a handpicked selection united by AMISH_FICTION, PENNSYLVANIA_FICTION, FICTION_RELIGIOUS, and SISTERS_FICTION.

Top related books to The Prodigal

Handpicked for thematic and literary overlap — the best shelf companions to The Prodigal.

The Last Bride (Home to Hickory Hollow)

Beverly Lewis

Themes: AMISH_FICTION • PENNSYLVANIA_FICTION

Sister Mine: A Novel — Tawni O’Dell

Tawni O'Dell

Themes: PENNSYLVANIA_FICTION • SISTERS_FICTION

An Amish Kitchen Three Amish Novellas

Beth Wiseman

Themes: AMISH_FICTION • PENNSYLVANIA_FICTION

The Amish Midwife (Volume 1) (The Women of Lancaster County)

Mindy Starns Clark

Themes: AMISH_FICTION • PENNSYLVANIA_FICTION

I Hear the Reaper’s Song: A Novel

Sara Stambaugh

Themes: PENNSYLVANIA_FICTION • FICTION_RELIGIOUS

Little Women

Louisa May Alcott

Themes: SISTERS_FICTION

Monsignor Quixote (Penguin Classics)

Graham Greene

Themes: FICTION_RELIGIOUS

April Witch: A Novel

Majgull Axelsson

Themes: SISTERS_FICTION

A Sister’s Secret

Wanda E. Brunstetter

Themes: AMISH_FICTION

#10

Vote for Me!

Robin Palmer

Themes: SISTERS_FICTION

#11

Cassandra’s Sister

Veronica Bennett

Themes: SISTERS_FICTION

#12

Unto the Soul

Aharon Appelfeld

Themes: FICTION_RELIGIOUS

#13

At Paradise Gate

Jane Smiley

Themes: SISTERS_FICTION

#14

The Last Sin Eater

Francine Rivers

Themes: FICTION_RELIGIOUS

#15

The Fall Of A Sparrow

Robert Hellenga

Themes: SISTERS_FICTION

#16

The Rock: A Tale of Seventh-Century Jerusalem

Kanan Makiya

Themes: FICTION_RELIGIOUS

#17

Die for Me

Karen Rose

Themes: PENNSYLVANIA_FICTION

#18

The Secret Life of Bees: Tie In Edition

Sue Monk Kidd

Themes: SISTERS_FICTION

#19

The Folly of the Three Wise Men

Edgar Whitaker Work

Themes: FICTION_RELIGIOUS

#20

Dead End in Norvelt (Norvelt Series, 1)

Jack Gantos

Themes: PENNSYLVANIA_FICTION

#21

Sadie: A Novel

Courtney Summers

Themes: SISTERS_FICTION

#22

From May to December

Pat MacEnulty

Themes: SISTERS_FICTION

#23

City of God — E. L. Doctorow

E.L. Doctorow

Themes: FICTION_RELIGIOUS

#24

Jacob the Baker: Gentle Wisdom For a Complicated World

Noah Benshea

Themes: FICTION_RELIGIOUS

This list brings together 24 books that share meaningful common ground with The Prodigal by Beverly Lewis. Connected by AMISH_FICTION, PENNSYLVANIA_FICTION, FICTION_RELIGIOUS. Authors featured include Beverly Lewis, Tawni O'Dell, Beth Wiseman, Mindy Starns Clark, and others. Each pick was selected for thematic and literary overlap — not just genre similarity.